| The Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers | 1 October 2009 | 30 September 2012 | 3 years and 0 days | Original justice | Senior Lord of Appeal in Ordinary (2008–2009) Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales (2005–2008) Master of the Rolls (2000–2005) Lord of Appeal in Ordinary (1999–2000) |
| The Lord Hope of Craighead | 1 October 2009 | 26 June 2013 | 3 years and 269 days | Original justice | Second Senior Lord of Appeal in Ordinary (2009) Lord of Appeal in Ordinary (1996–2009) Lord President of the Court of Session (1989–1996) |
| The Lord Saville of Newdigate | 1 October 2009 | 30 September 2010 | 1 year and 0 days | Original justice | Lord of Appeal in Ordinary (1997–2009) Lord Justice of Appeal (1994–1997) |
| The Lord Collins of Mapesbury | 1 October 2009 | 7 May 2011 | 1 year and 219 days | Original justice | Lord of Appeal in Ordinary (2009) Lord Justice of Appeal (2007–2009) |
| The Lord Rodger of Earlsferry | 1 October 2009 | 26 June 2011 | 1 year and 269 days | Original justice | Lord of Appeal in Ordinary (2001–2009) Lord President of the Court of Session (1996–2001) Senator of the College of Justice (1995–1996) |
| The Lord Brown of Eaton-under-Heywood | 1 October 2009 | 9 April 2012 | 2 years and 192 days | Original justice | Lord of Appeal in Ordinary (2004–2009) Lord Justice of Appeal (1992–2004) |
| The Lord Walker of Gestingthorpe | 1 October 2009 | 17 March 2013 | 3 years and 174 days | Original justice | Lord of Appeal in Ordinary (2002–2009) Lord Justice of Appeal (1997–2002) |
| The Lord Clarke of Stone-cum-Ebony | 1 October 2009 | 30 September 2017 | 8 years and 0 days | Original justice | Master of the Rolls (2005–2009) Lord Justice of Appeal (1998–2005) |
| The Lord Mance | 1 October 2009 | 6 June 2018 | 8 years and 249 days | Original justice | Lord of Appeal in Ordinary (2005–2009) Lord Justice of Appeal (1999–2005) |
| The Baroness Hale of Richmond | 1 October 2009 | 31 January 2020 | 10 years and 102 days | Original justice | Lord of Appeal in Ordinary (2004–2009) Lord Justice of Appeal (1999–2003) |
| The Lord Kerr of Tonaghmore | 1 October 2009 | 30 September 2020 | 11 years and 0 days | Original justice | Lord of Appeal in Ordinary (2009) Lord Chief Justice of Northern Ireland (2004–2009) |
| Lord Dyson | 13 April 2010 | 1 October 2012 | 2 years and 172 days | Original justice | Deputy Head of Civil Justice (2003–2006) Lord Justice of Appeal (2001–2010) |
| Lord Wilson of Culworth | 26 May 2011 | 9 May 2020 | 8 years and 350 days | The Lord Saville of Newdigate | Lord Justice of Appeal (2005–2011) |
| Lord Sumption | 11 January 2012 | 9 December 2018 | 6 years and 333 days | The Lord Collins of Mapesbury | None (Queen's Counsel (1986–2012)) |
| The Lord Reed of Allermuir | 6 February 2012 | Incumbent | 14 years and 264 days | The Lord Rodger of Earlsferry | Senator of the College of Justice (1998–2012) |
| Lord Carnwath of Notting Hill | 17 April 2012 | 15 March 2020 | 7 years and 334 days | The Lord Brown of Eaton-under-Heywood | Lord Justice of Appeal (2002–2012) |
| The Lord Neuberger of Abbotsbury | 1 October 2012 | 4 September 2017 | 4 years and 339 days | The Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers | Master of the Rolls (2009–2012) Lord of Appeal in Ordinary (2007–2009) Lord Justice of Appeal (2004–2007) |
| Lord Hughes of Ombersley | 9 April 2013 | 11 August 2018 | 5 years and 125 days | Lord Dyson | Vice President of the Criminal Division of the Court of Appeal (2009–2013) Lord Justice of Appeal (2006–2013) |
| Lord Toulson | 9 April 2013 | 22 September 2016 | 3 years and 167 days | The Lord Walker of Gestingthorpe | Lord Justice of Appeal (2006–2013) Chairman of the Law Commission (2002–2006) |
| Lord Hodge | 1 October 2013 | 31 December 2025 | 13 years and 27 days | The Lord Hope of Craighead | Senator of the College of Justice (2005–2013) |